Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?

deviantART

 

:iconjumpingbean:
Beautiful and sad and cruel. Your writing is lyrical and smooth and yet I can see the shifts in tone and style, from conversational and casual to factual to a clinical, dry tone. That paragraph about the method of death sounds like it was from a coroner's report. It's a smooth transition from being more personal to being emotionally distant, but then you abruptly shift back to a personal tone again, like you're shaking the memory away.

You did that well here - understating the deep emotions while letting your physical descriptions illustrate the depth of the speaker's feelings. I can feel the horror, too, without you ever having to state it.

There isn't really anything I would want to have changed in your piece, although I do wonder at what made the speaker's brother fly into a killing rage. But if you had put that in the story, I don't think the story would've flowed as well.

Just one correction, unless you meant for it to be this way: The "a" should be a capital "A" at the beginning of the last sentence in the third paragraph. Or the period between "friend" and "a friend" should be a comma instead.

I loved this piece.:heart:
The Artist thought this was FAIR
1 out of 1 deviants thought this was fair.

Comments


Devious Comments

:iconkahl:
I am very flattered by all this. I did make the suggested edit (yes, it should have been capitalized). I'm glad that the emotional distance was evident. I tried t tel the story from the perspective of someone who doesn't want to remember, feels a lot of guilt but is faced with the facts after so many years. Many times people in such a situation will revert to a third person perspective of themselves as a way to disassociate and cope. I stopped just shy of doing that.

Thank you for such a lovely, well written critique. :love:

--
You are AMAZING.

...just an earth-bound misfit, i
:iconjumpingbean:
You're welcome. :D I think it worked out much better that you stopped short of the third person perspective because the subtleness felt right. :smooch:

--
If it's in long...
If it's in hard...
If it's in deep...
Then by all societal conventions...it's in decent. ~ *Fangfingers

Site Map